Articles worth reading

Metro Manila News

vaping to be legal

Filipino vapers laud Quebec court’s decision rejecting anti-vaping law provisions

account_balanceMetro Manila chat_bubble_outline0 Comments

LOCAL vaping groups welcomed the Superior Court of Quebec’s recent decision rejecting key sections of the Tobacco Control Act adopted by the Quebec government in 2015, which sought to treat vaping products essentially the same as cigarettes. 

In his decision handed down on May 3, 2019 Justice Daniel Dumais accepted that cigarette smoking is a significant cause of preventable illness and death and declared that the evidence presented convinced the court that electronic cigarettes have been shown to be effective, for some people, in their efforts to quit smoking. 

The court was also convinced, in accordance with evidence presented, that using electronic cigarettes is less harmful to health than ordinary cigarettes; that it is better to vape than to smoke tobacco; and that vaping is a valid method to quit smoking.

The decision recognizes vaping as a form of harm reduction as it allows people who would otherwise smoke lethal cigarettes to get the nicotine they need or want without the inhalation of smoke. 

As the harm from cigarette use is overwhelmingly due to the inhalation of smoke rather than the nicotine, the decision underscores important lessons for harm reduction. 

The Quebec Superior Court is the highest trial Court in the province of Quebec in Canada. 

It is composed of 157 justices, including a Chief Justice, a Senior Associate Chief Justice, and an Associate Chief Justice. 

This recent development prompted the Philippine E-Cigarette Industry Association (PECIA) led by its president, Joey Dulay to air their groups plea for 

the Philippine Health department to consider the "emerging evidence supporting tobacco harm reduction and to be mindful of consumer rights".

"Like Quebec’s anti-vaping law, the recent Department of Health administrative order considers e-cigarettes as essentially the same as cigarettes, Dulay said in a statement sent to Metro News Central. 

Dulay is referring to DOH A.O. No. 2019-0007 released on June 14, 2019 which, among others, bans any form of advertising, promotion and sponsorship of vaping products; bans vaping in places where smoking is prohibited; sets guidelines and requirements for designated vaping areas that are identical with those for designated smoking areas; and prohibits the purchase, sale and offering for sale of e-cigarettes in places where sale and use of cigarettes are prohibited.

Meanwhile, another vaping group, The Vapers Philippines through its president Peter Paul Dator said that the Quebec court decision "underscores the inviolable right of consumers to be provided with accurate and complete information on and access to all available products so that they are able to make informed choices". 

It is a strong affirmation of the validity of tobacco harm reduction and sets an important legal precedent that will have persuasive value in other countries, including the Philippines,”Dator explained in a statement released to media recently. 

 

Vaping ban is a human rights violation

Among other things, Quebec’s Tobacco Control Act prohibited the promotion of vaping products and banned trials of such products at retailers. 

The Quebec Superior Court declared that these prohibitions prevented cigarette smokers in Quebec from hearing about the health benefits of switching to vaping products, from learning about how to use vaping products and from finding a product that is maximally able to replace their cigarettes.

The court further stated that denying smokers the option of trying vaping products in shops or in clinics is a violation of their rights, depriving them of access to a mechanism designed to reduce their risks and better protect their health. 

The court found that the legislated restrictions ignored the fact that the public, particularly smokers, do not distinguish between smoking and vaping.

In effect, the court acknowledged that it is sometimes necessary to educate and make people aware that vaping exists above all for smokers. 

Thus, those measures that prevented the display and trialing of products in vape shops and the communication of information to cigarette smokers on the relative risks of such products were violations of fundamental rights.

 

Respect human rights, empower consumers

According to Dator, the Quebec court’s decision is part of a global trend of courts striking down measures that seek to limit access to risk reduction strategies. 

He cited a recent Swiss Federal Supreme Court decision that used reasoning similar to the Quebec court decision in striking down a ban on snus, a low risk non-combustible Swedish tobacco product. 

Dator also pointed out that vaping products remain available in the US market as a result of a 2010 ruling by Judge Richard Leon of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia in the Sottera Inc. v. U.S. Food and Drug Administration case.

Dator cited the position of Prof. David Sweanor of the University of Ottawa Centre for Health Law, Policy and Ethics. “Moralistic abstinence-only policies, including those for nicotine, have a long history of being ineffective, undermining human rights and being ultimately overturned by courts. 

Far better to focus on effective rather than dramatic interventions, to seek to empower rather than to punish those at risk and to promote policies that respect human dignity and promote individual human rights.

date_rangeDate Published
4 months ago
shareShare article
folder_openArticle tags
content_copyCategorized under

Share your thoughts with us

Related Articles

Ph-SoKor agreement on social security

SSS welcomes PH-Korea deal on social security

account_balanceMetro Manila chrome_reader_mode5 days ago

State-run Social Security System (SSS) said more than 60,000 Filipinos in South Korea will soon enjoy the benefits of social security coverage and protection both from their host and mother countries following the signing of the bilateral agreem...

Manila Water, Maynilad drop arbitration claims

account_balanceMetro Manila chrome_reader_mode1 day ago

Concessionaires Manila Water and Maynilad Water are dropping their claims for billions of pesos in uncollected water rate hikes which were earlier awarded to them by international arbitration courts. The two firms said they would no longer ask the g...

Soldier athletes of the Philippine Army / PIA

Filipino soldiers win gold medals at 30th SEA Games

account_balanceMetro Manila chrome_reader_mode5 days ago

Several members of the Philippine Army bagged gold medals at various sports competitions in December 1 and 2 during the 30th South East Asian Games. They were able to win a total of seven gold medals from Speak Takraw, Arnis, Judo, and Basketball ev...

Comelec considering 'hybrid' 2022 elections

account_balanceMetro Manila chrome_reader_mode20 hours ago

The Commission on Elections (Comelec) plans to adopt a hybrid form of automated national elections in May 2022. “We have no recommendations yet. It’s been talked about. Our focus really is a hybridization of the AES (Automated Election S...

Farmers Market

Inflation rises slightly to 1.3%

account_balanceMetro Manila chrome_reader_mode5 days ago

Inflation rate slightly picked up to 1.3 percent in November from a 42-month low of 0.7 percent in October, but the government said it is not a cause for concern/ Headline inflation slightly inched up after a five-month slowdown in price i...

Munti robotics fair

Colegio de Muntinlupa holds robotics fair

account_balanceMuntinlupa chrome_reader_mode23 hours ago

Mayor Jaime Fresnedi visited booths and learns robotics projects from student-innovators at the 2nd Robotics Fair of Colegio de Muntinlupa, Sucat. CDM hosted this year’s division fair, in partnership with Department of Science and Te...

Advertisement